Mayor’s animal task force set to meet today to discuss recent audit

Mayor Robert Garcia today will hold the first meeting of the Long Beach Animal Care Vision Task Force. Members include animal advocates, volunteers, rescuers and residents who simply love animals and want the best possible outcomes for them.

The task force was formed in response to phase one of the Office of the City Auditor’s Animal Care Services Review and to the demands of residents of the city who are devoted to animal welfare. The review identified nearly 200 recommendations for short-term and long-term improvements as well as best practices for the shelter at Long Beach Animal Care Services. Staffing, medical care and feeding, spay and neuter, live-release rates, funding and fostering were covered extensively, as was forming community partnerships.

The task force is the most significant development to come from the audit. It’s dedicated to address the issues specified in both phase one and phase two, which was released to the public on Aug. 27.

Long Beach Animal Care Services, according to the review, ranks sixth out of nine municipal shelters in live animal release (to include rescues, adoptions and owner return). The review acknowledged the limitations of the benchmark comparison. Demographics and population differ, and there is wide variation among the shelters with regard to services, staffing and management approaches.

“Shelters could service animal and human populations with different needs; enforce different, city-specific animal related laws; incur different shelter maintenance costs; and perform tasks that other shelters do not, such as answering citizen calls for service in-house, rather than outsourcing that duty to another department,” the review reads.

ACS ranks below average; factors such as demographics and procedures may affect the ranking. Graphic courtesy of the Office of the City Auditor.

The study was far from a disparagement. The review took into account the “noteworthy strides” that ACS has made in lowering euthanasia rate and in increasing live release.

“We are proud of ACS for their continued commitment to adopting more animals and reducing euthanasia rates,” Garcia said in a written statement. “The auditor’s report, which I requested as a way to identify opportunities for improvements, makes clear that we still have much more to do, and I look forward to working with the city manager to implement the auditor’s recommendations.”

Phase Two further developed and identified a total of 186 needs, summing them up as a three-prong program: implementing standard operating procedures, developing a shared vision and strategic plan to set priorities, and reviewing resources and maximizing revenue to implement them. Conspicuous in the report was an estimated $1 million in uncollected fines and citations. The shelter was also noted to be understaffed and operating above its limitations; it’s a conundrum to consider that the staff required to collect these fines might be funded by the fines themselves.

“Advocates have been asking for years to hire more staff,” said Judy Crumpton, a longtime animal-welfare champion, task force member and former co-writer of The Scratching Post. “I feel it especially needs to be full-time employees with benefits—this also includes more vets and field officers. Without a doubt, there is money out there in uncollected citations and licensing fees; however, there is not enough staff to go after it. At this time, it’s either take care of the animals or go after the fees. Once more staff is on board, much more can be accomplished throughout the needs of the shelter—increasing employee morale is very important.”

Task force members expect to address such issues as expediting adoption, strengthening the volunteer program and developing a process that will more quickly identify and move pets to rescues. Continuing to reduce the intake and euthanasia rates at the shelter, increasing partnerships with outside rescues, and managing adoption rates are critical goals for task force member Diana Kliché. Kliché is president of Fix Long Beach, an all-volunteer organization that offers free spay/neuter procedures and low-cost vaccinations to residents who couldn’t otherwise afford them.

Euthanasia and live-release rates have been going in the right direction since 2011, in part thanks to efforts by Fix Long Beach which relies on ACS for voucher support, and by Friends of Long Beach Animals and its voucher program.

On Aug. 29, the city released a statement that included graphics showing the progress up to August of this year.

Live-release and euthanasia rates have steadily gone in the right direction since 2011, thanks to joint efforts by the shelter and the community. Graphics courtesy of ACS.


“The information [in the review] was based on 2016 statistics, and there was an improvement over 2017 and 2018,” said ACS manager Ted Stevens. “It’s important to get the message out there.”

Rescue release, however, needs to occur with more consistency and rapidity while at the same time working out the best placement for the pet, said one rescuer, particularly those with medical issues. Stevens said that ACS has networked animals in the stray hold period and that needed surgery; rescues that were willing to provide the treatment when the vet team was overburdened.

“The sooner we can find out about an animal, the more time we have to network and develop a plan for getting that animal to safety,” said Helen Sanders CatPAWS volunteer Deborah Felin.

There have certainly been improvements and developments at the shelter: the recent hires of a full-time adoption coordinator and a community information specialist along with construction of a dog play area and specialized volunteer training for the play area. An enhanced foster program is already underway with the support of Friends of Long Beach Animals, Long Beach’s longest-standing animal-welfare volunteer organizations and a location for a newborn-kitten nursery is presently under negotiation. The latter is a collaborative project of The Little Lion Foundation, Helen Sanders CatPAWS and ACS.

The review’s results and later developments at ACS may have passed each other like ships in the night—City Auditor Laura Doud acknowledged this and looks at the improvements as bellwethers of things to come.

“I am pleased that this two-part review is serving as a catalyst and guide to the city and stakeholders to begin a new chapter for the shelter,” she said. “Management has taken steps to address the 186 recommendations from both phase one and two.”

Councilwoman Stacy Mungo obtained one-time funds to hire a consultant to work with ACS, the mayor’s task force and others to help map out a vision for the shelter. This promises to be a challenge, but even with a diversity of opinion and experience, task force members are all there for one reason.

“It’s everybody’s shelter dilemma,” Crumpton said. “I also hope that we can have a few members of our shelter staff there and see what they have to say. After so many years in this community, I’m hoping that we’ll have a meeting of the minds and be productive.”

 More information about the task force meetings will be posted on ACS’s home page as it becomes available.


Support our journalism.

Hyperlocal news is an essential force in our democracy, but it costs money to keep an organization like this one alive, and we can’t rely on advertiser support alone. That’s why we’re asking readers like you to support our independent, fact-based journalism. We know you like it—that’s why you’re here. Help us keep hyperlocal news alive in Long Beach.

Kate Karp is the Pets Columnist for the Long Beach Post covering the world of animal activism, pet adoptions and lots of cute cats. She’s called Long Beach home since 1994 and has written for the Post for about 10 years. Kate’s day job is as a copyeditor, which she discovered a love for during her 30-year tenure as a teacher. She describes the job as “like taking the rough edges off a beautiful sculpture.”