Under the pending ban, takeout boxes like this would be illegal in Long Beach. File photo
Long Beach’s ban on expanded polystyrene (styrofoam) will have to wait a little longer, after the city council voted last night to allow for more time to consult with businesses and other stakeholders on what that ban could potentially look like.
The council’s vote last night will extend a deadline for an ordinance to return to the chamber for a vote by 60 days and include additional outreach to small business owners. If adopted, the ban would halt the sales of styrofoam products and the distribution of disposable food service containers made out of styrofoam.
The ban would include a one-year phase-in element and include hardship waivers for those businesses that can provide proof that switching to an alternative would be too costly.
The item was brought to the council by First District Councilwoman Lena Gonzalez, who held a rally outside city hall prior to the meeting to drum up support for a #FoamFree Long Beach. She said expanded polystyrene represented one of the biggest issues to the city’s beaches and streets in terms of pollution and said that more eco-friendly alternatives appeared to be affordable for those businesses that could be impacted by the ban.
“I know there might be a cost impact but relative to what you’re seeing here you’re seeing the cost differential is very low,” Gonzalez said. “In some cases the cost differentials are cost-neutral and in some cases they are [a] one cent cost difference.”
The foam is not biodegradable, and while technically considered a recyclable material, it rarely finds a second life as a new material because of the high costs associated with cleaning and harvesting it once it’s been thrown out. If Long Beach were to indeed enact a ban, completing a process that was started by this council over a decade ago, it could join dozens of other cities in the state that have already taken steps to curb their styrofoam problem.
Katie Allen, the executive director at Algalita Marine Research and Education, a leader in the fight to keep plastics out of the world’s oceans, said its recent survey of the Long Beach Peninsula yielded over 2,100 pieces of the substance in just ten liters of sand. She said the foam often breaks down into smaller pieces that make it easier to enter the food system and harder for volunteers to remove from beaches. Banning the substance was the second most important action item in the group’s survey.
“We’re literally changing the composition of our ocean and our beaches,” Allen said. “These microplastics soak up toxins and may be entering our local food chains. They become bite-sized morsels for the fish, turtles and other animals living in our ecosystem. Beyond that, the individuals in our communities feed their families fish collected from this highly polluted area.”
Plastic in the ocean is a growing worldwide issue. At the beginning of 2016 the World Economic Forum released a study that predicted that by the year 2050 there would be more pounds of plastic in the world’s oceans than pounds of fish. The study also estimated that nearly all of the world’s seabirds have ingested plastic at some point in their lifetimes.
A large group of supporters filled the council chambers and lined up to plead with the city council to enact a ban with some citing the potential health risks of the substance—the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) lists it as a possible human carcinogen that is capable of leaching into food—and one man stating that the incoming White House administration has now placed environmental protection at the feet of local representatives.
“Given the political environment in Washington, and given the fact that we have someone who has proposed a climate change denier who may be the head of the EPA, we have to look to you all more than ever to kind of lead by example,” said Robert Nothoff, the director of Don’t Waste Long Beach, a local environmental coalition.
The few voices that spoke against the council directing the city attorney’s office from beginning the drafting process of an ordinance for it to approve were from the restaurant industry. Although business owners from Lola’s Mexican Cuisine and Berlin Bistro voiced their support and noted their personal bands, others expressed concerns that the business community was either unaware of the council’s planned vote last night or that potentially affected parties were not engaged enough in the process to provide input toward what the ordinance would entail.
While the council’s vote did approve the process of drafting an ordinance to begin, city staff and various city commissions will provide platforms for interested parties to voice their opinions on the matter—opinions that could eventually help tilt the direction of the ban in terms of penalties, exemptions and incentives for those complying with the ban. The ordinance is expected to return within 180 days, but it could be sooner if the process is completed before the six-month window closes.
Long Beach was one of the leaders in the effort to ban plastic bags from retail stores, something that was eventually adopted by the state and upheld by voters in last month’s election. Mayor Robert Garcia, who last year signed on to a Compact of Mayors that pledged to reduce greenhouse gasses and take up a strong stance on climate change, said the expanded polystyrene ban could be similar to the bag issue with cities taking the initial lead and the state following suit.
“I think Long Beach led the way on the plastic bag issue, it was a tough vote; we led the way, more cities followed and the state went and did their work,” Garcia said. “In this case, a lot of cities have done the work already and Long Beach can help lead the way and eventually what I think will happen is the state will follow and we’ll end up with a statewide policy.”
Jason Ruiz covers transportation for the Long Beach Post. Reach him at [email protected] or 951-310-1772.
Free news isn’t cheap.
We believe that everyone should have access to important local news, for free.
However, it costs money to keep a local news organization like this one—independently owned and operated here in Long Beach, without the backing of any national corporation—alive.
If independent local news is important to you, please consider supporting us with a monthly or one-time contribution. Read more.