UPDATE FRIDAY MARCH 7, 2008: The Wall Street Journal is reporting this morning that the Board of Directors of two of the major home builders in the country, Toll Brothers and KB Homes, are looking to restructure the bonus plans and calculations for their CEOs so they can increase their bonuses for 2007. Under the proposed revision at Toll Brothers CEO Robert Toll would see his bonus for 2007 (when the builder lost money) increase from $1.36 million to $6.56 million—or enough to pay for the tax credits of 656 buyers of his new homes under the proposal his professional association is pressuring Congress to pass. Just to clarify: the National Association of Home Builders is requesting Congress to pass a $10,000 for those purchasing new construction homes to help builders reduce their inventory while members of the Association are looking to increase the bonuses paid to CEOs be several million dollars.
Just saw a news release that the National Association of Home Builders is asking the Senate to “quickly pass” a $10,000 tax credit for homebuyers. They want this to reduce their inventory and to stimulate the housing market. Why don’t they just lower their asking prices? Tax payers are being asked to subsidize people purchasing new homes so the builders can maintain their profit margins? That is chutzpah!
The argument by the NAHB of helping “to stimulate the housing sector and prevent the economy from spiraling into recession” is just laughable. The only concern the NAHB has is for the profits of their members, which is understandable, to use tax payer money to support and generate those profits however is wrong. The builders have excess inventory because they built too many homes for the market. Because of their inability to properly gauge the market they should be bailed out? Again, if you have excess inventory lower your price or hold the inventory, do not ask the government to create a false market using our tax dollars.
What about people purchasing existing homes? Why should they not get a tax credit for $10,000? At least that would help two families: the family purchasing the home and the family selling the home. Homeowners already get a very good tax credit, the mortgage interest deduction. While that deduction may get repealed for
I will repeat what I have been saying for years, but more frequently for the past several months: the government position on the “bailouts” for the housing industry should be limited to a) raising the loan limits—which has been passed and should be effective in the next few weeks and b) create a national lending license that every individual in the country who takes applications for home loans and mortgages must hold—every mortgage broker, every S&L loan officer, every credit union employee, every direct lender, every website customer service mortgage advisor; all of us must go through a difficult process and exam to get a National Mortgage Lending License. No more credits, bailouts, payments, judicial renegotiation of notes, let the markets do their job.
Current estimates are that the mortgage losses that started with the sub-prime market melt down last spring will be approximately $400-600 billion; for some perspective the Dow Jones Industrial Average has a capitalization rate of approximately $4 trillion. That means the estimated losses from the mortgage losses is anywhere from 10 – 15% of the Dow—roughly the amount lost between December and the end of February for the Dow…and from last Tuesday to yesterday for Google; should the government be bailing out those who bought Google last Tuesday?
By the way, I saw that one of the golf stores is having a sale to “blow out” excess inventory–how about a $500 credit so I can get some new wedges and we can also stimulate the golf industry?
This comment originally posted on the Blog on my personal mortgage website at www.denniscsmith.com
Your thoughts welcome, click here to email me or on “Leave A Comment” below for public response.